7 answers
CareerVillage Office Hours
Student
Palo Alto, California
589
Questions
Asked
655 views
What guidance would you give on making a difficult decision when it differs from the majority view?
What guidance would you give on making a difficult decision when it differs from the majority view?
Login to comment
7 answers
Marlene Galvan
performance and accountability
7
Answers
Chandler, Arizona
Updated
Marlene’s Answer
Be prepared to give the WHY behind your decision and be prepared to answer hard questions.
Jerome Dees Jr.
Sales Professional and Networking Expert
854
Answers
San Francisco, California
Updated
Jerome’s Answer
Situations like these are a reason why having long-term goals can be very helpful. If the decision you’re making, will help you get closer to your ideal outcome, then it might be worth going against the flow.
On the other hand, depending on the situation, understand, understanding why people around you feel differently could help alter your views.
We will never get every decision right, but I think you are on the right track and trying to ask the right questions to make the best decision.
On the other hand, depending on the situation, understand, understanding why people around you feel differently could help alter your views.
We will never get every decision right, but I think you are on the right track and trying to ask the right questions to make the best decision.
PwC Impact
823
Answers
Orlando, Florida
Updated
PwC’s Answer
The first step I would take when my decision differs from the majority view is to ask myself whether I want my position to be correct simply because it is my own, or whether there are objective facts and indicators suggesting that the outcome may differ from the majority view. This helps prevent confirmation bias.
I would also challenge myself by asking questions that could reveal weaknesses in my analysis and determine whether I can logically defend my position. Additionally, I would assess the risks of moving forward with my perspective, especially if I am not 100% certain that I am correct.
If I ultimately turn out to be wrong, I would not take it personally. Instead, I would reflect on why the other perspective differed from mine and use it as a learning opportunity.
I would also challenge myself by asking questions that could reveal weaknesses in my analysis and determine whether I can logically defend my position. Additionally, I would assess the risks of moving forward with my perspective, especially if I am not 100% certain that I am correct.
If I ultimately turn out to be wrong, I would not take it personally. Instead, I would reflect on why the other perspective differed from mine and use it as a learning opportunity.
PwC Impact
823
Answers
Orlando, Florida
Updated
PwC’s Answer
- Focus the group on the problem itself and why your view will solve the problem rather than defending your solution against other solutions or pointing to flaws in the majority view.
- Logic and reasoning with a humanist perspective
- Logic and reasoning with a humanist perspective
PwC Impact
823
Answers
Orlando, Florida
Updated
PwC’s Answer
- I would say to put yourself on each others shoes, understand different points of view, acknowledging them but ultimately weigh pros and cons based on your own situation with clarity. Don’t duel on it as usually if it is a difficult decision, both answers could ultimately be a good answer.
- At the end of the day, you have to be able to live in your decisions and all you have is your reputation. Being brave is the name of the game. You have to be honest with and true to yourself. And the universe will reward your bravery and you living in your truth.
- Be confident in your perspective, but be willing and able to explain why it’s what you believe. The best decisions are reached by those who have weighed different options and there is value in the pros and cons of alternatives, regardless of whether they are ultimately chosen.
- At the end of the day, you have to be able to live in your decisions and all you have is your reputation. Being brave is the name of the game. You have to be honest with and true to yourself. And the universe will reward your bravery and you living in your truth.
- Be confident in your perspective, but be willing and able to explain why it’s what you believe. The best decisions are reached by those who have weighed different options and there is value in the pros and cons of alternatives, regardless of whether they are ultimately chosen.
PwC Impact
823
Answers
Orlando, Florida
Updated
PwC’s Answer
- State your case in a respectful way. Articulate your position. But if your point of view doesn't "win", be gracious and move on. You may have the opportunity to revisit some day. Don't burn bridges over a point of view.
- Listen to others. Gather as much information as possible. Be open to different opinions. And when the time has come, make your own, independent, decisions. Be receptive before deciding, so you can go beyond your own biases, and be confident once you've decided. Explain your reasons and be persuasive.
- I try to make decisions based on the facts I know at the time, my intuition, and advice from mentors.
- History is full of examples where the majority viewpoint was far from being the correct or best decision. The right decision will be the right decision regardless of how many people may disagree.
- For it is the amount of resistance in the path that decides how much valuable the goal is... Hence if the decision is morally and ethically correct, provided it does not harm others interests and if its pros outweigh the cons - one must take the leap of faith.
- Listen to others. Gather as much information as possible. Be open to different opinions. And when the time has come, make your own, independent, decisions. Be receptive before deciding, so you can go beyond your own biases, and be confident once you've decided. Explain your reasons and be persuasive.
- I try to make decisions based on the facts I know at the time, my intuition, and advice from mentors.
- History is full of examples where the majority viewpoint was far from being the correct or best decision. The right decision will be the right decision regardless of how many people may disagree.
- For it is the amount of resistance in the path that decides how much valuable the goal is... Hence if the decision is morally and ethically correct, provided it does not harm others interests and if its pros outweigh the cons - one must take the leap of faith.
Michael Gigliotti
Manager
5
Answers
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Updated
Michael’s Answer
Just because a decision goes against the majority, it does not make it wrong. The most important thing you need in conveying a difficult decision is the reasoning behind the decision. Make sure you have turned over every stone. Make sure you have looked at the same decision from the opposing viewpoint. When it comes time to communicate, explain the reasoning and be as transparent as possible. You may not change every heart, but most people will at least be able to come to grips with the decision if they understand the "why". Don't discredit the majority's viewpoint, but respect their intelligence to see and understand your reasoning.