Skip to main content
5 answers
8
Asked 1045 views

Mechanical Engineering Master's or Master's degree in Orthotics and Prosthetics?

I'm currently a Biomedical Engineering undergrad planning to work in the field of prosthetics. I've heard the BME job market isn't the best right now, so I was planning on doing an accelerated program with my university that would allow me to graduate with my mechanical engineering master's in the same 4 years as my BME bachelor degree. I thought this was a good idea to get more prosthetic knowledge overall and make my resume more competitive. I recently found out that if I want to work with patients and design prosthetics, I would need a specific master's degree in Orthotics and Prosthetics. This degree isn't offered at my university or many universities in general. I would have to spend 2 years pursuing this degree plus a 12-18 month residency. I'm questioning doing this because I don't want to spend the time doing this degree and boxing myself in. If I do the Master's degree in Orthotics and Prosthetics instead of mechanical engineering, I don't think I would have as much room to pivot fields if I decide to. I believe I can still create prosthetics with a BME or mechanical degree, but I just won't get to work directly with patients.


8

5 answers


0
Updated
Share a link to this answer
Share a link to this answer

Aaron’s Answer

Hi Esther,

If you are unsure whether you want to work in patient care or industry, I recommend shadowing at a local orthotics and prosthetics clinic to get a feel for what the patient care side is like. Every MSOP school across the country requires shadowing hours prior to accepting you as a student, so this is a natural first step if you decide to go that route. Since all clinicians must shadow before becoming licensed professionals, many are excited to help the next generation.

While you are correct that the time commitment is significant to become a licensed professional and it does "box you in" to a career path to a certain degree, I know many former clinicians who have changed career paths to go work for an orthotics or prosthetics manufacturer or for a university as a teacher. A master's degree in mechanical engineering will certainly give you greater flexibility to work in more fields and give you the credentials needed to design orthotic or prosthetic componentry that ultimately goes on patients for a manufacturer; however, it may also make it more difficult to get into a niche field like prosthetics that is smaller and highly competitive.

Good luck in your journey!
Aaron
Thank you comment icon I didn't know about the shadowing requirements, so thank you for letting me know about that! Your advice is very helpful. Esther
0
0
Updated
Share a link to this answer
Share a link to this answer

Heike’s Answer

Hi there,

You're asking the right question because these are actually two different careers within the prosthetics field. First, determine which part of prosthetics excites you most. Ask yourself:

Do you enjoy engineering, product design, mechanics, robotics, and developing new technology?
Or do you enjoy working directly with patients, assessing their needs, fitting devices, and helping them regain mobility?

The answer to that question matters more than the degree title.

My perspective:
Based on your concerns about maintaining career flexibility, the accelerated Mechanical Engineering master's appears to give you more options while still positioning you for careers in prosthetics engineering, medical devices, biomechanics, robotics, and other engineering fields.

If, after some research like shadowing clinicians, speaking with professionals, and/or review job postings and job descriptions, you discover that your passion is specifically working directly with patients and fitting custom prosthetic devices, then pursuing the Orthotics & Prosthetics master's may be worth the additional time and specialization.
Thank you comment icon Thank you for your response, I do need to figure out what matters to me more. Shadowing should help me with this, so thank you for that suggestion! Esther
0
0
Updated
Share a link to this answer
Share a link to this answer

William’s Answer

Hi Esther,
Thank you very much for this thoughtful question. I do appreciate your current situation. Opportunities that come your way can be life changing. Personally, I would advice you to take up the opportunity to do the Masters in Mechanical Engineering - it saves time on your side. Your desk will be a little more crowded though. Your time management skills should be top-notch so you can effectively and efficiently cope with the increased workload.
Mechanical Engineering is a pathway to a wide range of fields of specialized study. Interest in, love for and enjoyment of what you do remains critical for a successful career. Orthotics and Prosthetics will give you the opportunity to respond to the needs of a significant portion of our population who seek solutions to their physical impairments and life changing independence.
Excellence has a way of making you stand out - embrace it with grace. Practical knowledge can be your enduring competitive advantage if you are really good at what you do. Take every available opportunity to acquire it: projects, internships, mentorships, apprenticeships & membership to professional bodies.
Good luck in your studies and career. I'm very confident that you will make it.
Thank you comment icon Thank you so much for your encouragement! I appreciate your answer, and I will definitely take advantage of, and embrace, every opportunity. Esther
0
0
Updated
Share a link to this answer
Share a link to this answer

Sreedhar’s Answer

Hi Esther,
Stay in your current university and wrap up your master's degree ASAP. I would recommend one of the two below options.
1. Master's degree in Biomedical Engineering. With this option, there is no need for a specialized area like Orthotics and Prosthetics. Just do a thesis or final project that is related to your field of interest.

2. Master's degree in Mechanical Engineering. During this, select one or two design courses in which you will design and build a physical product related to your field of interest at the end of the semester.

Good luck!

Sreedhar
Thank you comment icon Thank you for your response! I will look into these options. Esther
0
0
Updated
Share a link to this answer
Share a link to this answer

Robert’s Answer

Hi Esther,
Heike’s answer is an excellent one. She even hit upon some of the most meaningful aspects that helped me enormously as a fledgling BME: meeting with professionals in the fields of interest. I learned so much by arranging get-togethers with doctors, BMEs, MEs, etc. I’d ask college counselors, HR departments, and friends of family to help set up a coffee break or lunch time with an appropriate professional. It’s a worthwhile part of your decision process. Best of luck!
Thank you comment icon Thank you for your advice! I will definitely look into shadowing. Esther
0