14 answers
Andrew
Student
Colorado Springs, Colorado
1
Question
Asked
2916 views
Where do I go from here?
I am not a student, technically speaking, but rather a mid-life professional seeking more of a specific direction with my career.
In brief, I obtained an international PhD in a field related to the humanities and published my research as a monograph. However, after approximately five years of applying for teaching positions I was not able to obtain a position beyond an adjunct role teaching online for low pay at two schools. I currently hold two-part time jobs: both of them recently passed me up for promotions, and one has just started laying people off (I'm feeling quite vulnerable in that regard).
Aside from the pursuit of higher education, I've honestly been 'lost' as far as what other direction might be worth pursuing in which I would thrive. I am not even sure what questions to ask, but I would certainly appreciate any thoughts, advice, willingness to make new contacts, or any other assistance that you might deem valuable. It will be much appreciated. Thank you!
13 answers
Michelle M.
Actress
3276
Answers
Updated
Michelle’s Answer
Hello, Andrew !
Wow - a published monograph in your field is quite an accomplishment and shows that you are very focused and disciplined to undertake that work ! That's great ! I would like to provide you with some advice or ideas. I went from a primary career to a secondary different career and then back to my primary career past mid-life, LOL ! So it can be done !
Having a Doctorate degree tends to over qualify some for jobs, but that doesn't mean that you cannot make teaching and research new and exciting. The issue is, you have to be qualified for whatever field of work you transition to. I am not sure which segment of Humanities is your niche, but I think I can suggest some ideas to just think about.
I would suggest staying with Education and Research, but try something different. The jobs you have now are great, but keep applying for professorships at Universities - don't give up. In addition, venture into some new realms. Consider teaching your subject at The City of Colorado Springs Community Centers where they offer classes for adults and seniors. The Cottonwood Center for the Arts offers adult classes, too, where you can teach your subject(s). Consider teaching ESL at the Accompaniment and Sanctuary Coalition Colorado Springs at the Wasson Campus. You can teach English as a Second Language and Basic Education at The Adult and Family Education program through District 11. The Pillar Institute for Lifelong Learning might also be a place to check out for a teaching opportunity. I know, it's not a university, but the change of atmosphere may prove to be refreshing and maybe a change of environment and pace is what you may need. Remember, you will continue to keep an eye on positions at Universities.
A new and exciting experience for you may also come in considering being a Montessori or Waldorf teacher. You'd have to get their training, but this will add a new dimension to your teaching experience. Also consider being a Homeschool teacher. Register at Indeed and other employment websites because there are some families that actually hire out for homeschool teachers for their child. This can be done on site or remote. Try registering at Jooble, ZipRecruiter, Modulo Learning Inc. and Spark Learn Tutoring. Create a profile on Linked In if you haven't one already and follow universities, colleges and any places that you'd like employment from. I almost forgot - explore your local Department of Labor because sometimes they carry notices for some very good positions.
It may not be so difficult if you think "different direction' rather than a "specific direction". Your time spent exploring will be well worth it. I hope this helps and I wish you all the best !
Wow - a published monograph in your field is quite an accomplishment and shows that you are very focused and disciplined to undertake that work ! That's great ! I would like to provide you with some advice or ideas. I went from a primary career to a secondary different career and then back to my primary career past mid-life, LOL ! So it can be done !
Having a Doctorate degree tends to over qualify some for jobs, but that doesn't mean that you cannot make teaching and research new and exciting. The issue is, you have to be qualified for whatever field of work you transition to. I am not sure which segment of Humanities is your niche, but I think I can suggest some ideas to just think about.
I would suggest staying with Education and Research, but try something different. The jobs you have now are great, but keep applying for professorships at Universities - don't give up. In addition, venture into some new realms. Consider teaching your subject at The City of Colorado Springs Community Centers where they offer classes for adults and seniors. The Cottonwood Center for the Arts offers adult classes, too, where you can teach your subject(s). Consider teaching ESL at the Accompaniment and Sanctuary Coalition Colorado Springs at the Wasson Campus. You can teach English as a Second Language and Basic Education at The Adult and Family Education program through District 11. The Pillar Institute for Lifelong Learning might also be a place to check out for a teaching opportunity. I know, it's not a university, but the change of atmosphere may prove to be refreshing and maybe a change of environment and pace is what you may need. Remember, you will continue to keep an eye on positions at Universities.
A new and exciting experience for you may also come in considering being a Montessori or Waldorf teacher. You'd have to get their training, but this will add a new dimension to your teaching experience. Also consider being a Homeschool teacher. Register at Indeed and other employment websites because there are some families that actually hire out for homeschool teachers for their child. This can be done on site or remote. Try registering at Jooble, ZipRecruiter, Modulo Learning Inc. and Spark Learn Tutoring. Create a profile on Linked In if you haven't one already and follow universities, colleges and any places that you'd like employment from. I almost forgot - explore your local Department of Labor because sometimes they carry notices for some very good positions.
It may not be so difficult if you think "different direction' rather than a "specific direction". Your time spent exploring will be well worth it. I hope this helps and I wish you all the best !
Hi Michelle, Thank you so much for this very specific advice with some wonderful ideas. I will certainly take each of these potential options on board as I continue navigating this odd time of my professional life.
Andrew
Annah Edmonds
Licensed Clinical Counselor and Art Therapist
221
Answers
Seattle, Washington
Updated
Annah’s Answer
Andrew, I am guessing academia is saturated right now; a PhD is no small thing by the way- a huge achievement! While I am not sure what your specific field of expertise is- or what you consider special talents, skills or interests, this is a time when people are forging their own way, degree or no degree. What I mean by this is that you are in a great position to take an alternative path- with everything you already know from years of study and teaching. Have you considered teaching at a lower level, like high school? Or pursuing an international teaching position. You might work on educational material, curriculum planning, or programming for instance. If you are interested in something more holistic, coaching, mentoring, or tutoring might be a fit. Getting your voice out there and known may also be useful- get writing for peer-reviewed publications or journals. Perhaps submit your work to more mainstream magazines or online sites as well. If all else fails, create your own platform or join something like Substack. I know many people in academia who spent years building their successful careers; it took time. I also know people who left to be their own bosses and escape the structure of a more traditional type of career. Sometimes casting your net wide is the key. Some university roles have a timeline attached and it is important to always be ready for change or piecing things together. A great question to ask yourself is- do you still want to pursue the same type of work or try something a bit different? When we put so much effort, time, and money into our studies it can be a sticky thing to then wonder what we actually want- our ideal outcome. Getting clear on this may also give you some information about what to do next. No matter what you decide to do, your dedication will pay off. In this economy, many of us with higher education end up diversifying and taking on extra work out of necessity. It is simply the reality of entering a field that is competitive and/or not as high paying as others. Employees may also be holding onto their current jobs for longer due to their own concerns about finding similar work or other/economic fears. Take a hard look at all your strengths and leverage this for yourself. Everything is truly temporary; these difficult times will pass. In the meantime, you might find out you have more opportunities than you first thought. Get busy networking, volunteering your time, getting your unique voice out there to be appreciated, and see what pans out. You are likely not alone in this situation; I also know firsthand the pain of having a dream not unfold the way you expect. Talk with people in positions you want; ask them what they had to do to gain academic status. It might put things into perspective. I wish you the best!
I had considered high school teaching but my heart just isn't with that age group. Repeated experience shows me that my heart is strongly with the 18-25 year old crowd, but I just don't have the patience for younger ages. I'd thought about substitute teaching as well, but am looking for something more stable. I am not, of course, opposed to teaching on a limited basis internationally -- even up to a semester at a time. But again, stability is a primary motivating factor these days.
Excellent thoughts and ideas here. Thank you so much for your time in answering my question!
Andrew
James Constantine Frangos
SOFTWARE ENGINEER SINCE 1972; NUTRITIONIST SINCE 1976.
7094
Answers
Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia
Updated
James Constantine’s Answer
Good Day Andrew!
You have talent, now please get visible to the people! Why? You definitely know how to help people! A personal website shall help!
PLEASE SHOW YOUR FACE - WORK ON THE NETWORKING:- Network methods include: - ‣ Swap business cards ‣ Give out your business pamphlets at expositions
‣ Go to industry meetings ‣ Swap phone numbers ‣ Indeed, LinkedIn ‣ Join a network group ‣ Utilize social media ‣ Let people pick your brain at seminars answer their questions ‣ Grow a database of new friends, and professional business contacts ‣ Join industry groups ‣ Attend conventions and conferences ‣ Send cold emails ‣ Set up informational interviews ‣ Offer assistance ‣ Attend group network events to introduce yourself ‣ Attend industry-related conferences ‣ Join online communities ‣ Participate in online forums ‣ Meet new contacts for coffee ‣ Reach out to potential contacts via email or social network sites ‣ Ask friends to introduce you to their contacts as a reliable person ‣ Stay in touch with former coworkers ‣ Go to shows with people
HERE IS MORE!
‣ Get invited to people's houses to have meals with them and watch movies and shows ‣ Hold public discussion groups ‣ Meet with Parents' and Teachers' Association Groups ‣ Get to know and talk to your local medical doctors ‣ Meet with neighborhood clubs ‣ Meet with local health action groups ‣ Join public speaking groups like Toastmasters and Zonta ‣ Meet people at a fancy restaurant, sit down, talk, have meals together ‣ Pay your waiter a tab and converse ‣ Give local schoolchildren a talk about your work so that they can follow in your footsteps and get a career happening ‣ Get to know therapists. GIVE PEOPLE VALUABLE GIFTS. VOLUNTEER.
There are many professions that you could do with a doctorate in a humanities field. One is tutoring. I have been doing it since 1975. Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary students. It is a good source of instant income!
Another is a researcher, in a situation like a remote intern for a university department. They shall know you have a capacity for research as a doctorate armed with the numerous Internet specialist search engines.
You could advertise yourself as a Business Consultant and a Doctor [not medical!], as a PhD., you can use the title. While it is good to have a Master of Business Administration for the business advisor, some consultants are not as qualified! You probably know the reason why many businesses fail! The reason is that the managers carry-on and ignorantly deliberate and procrastinate about important remedial procedures that could rescue the entity.
You want to enter into a specialty without much further studies. There are many successful entrepreneurs too, without doctorates or degrees. If you have a product or service that people desire, or a method that enables them to cope with the latest version of life, then you can win.
GOD BLESS!
You have talent, now please get visible to the people! Why? You definitely know how to help people! A personal website shall help!
PLEASE SHOW YOUR FACE - WORK ON THE NETWORKING:- Network methods include: - ‣ Swap business cards ‣ Give out your business pamphlets at expositions
‣ Go to industry meetings ‣ Swap phone numbers ‣ Indeed, LinkedIn ‣ Join a network group ‣ Utilize social media ‣ Let people pick your brain at seminars answer their questions ‣ Grow a database of new friends, and professional business contacts ‣ Join industry groups ‣ Attend conventions and conferences ‣ Send cold emails ‣ Set up informational interviews ‣ Offer assistance ‣ Attend group network events to introduce yourself ‣ Attend industry-related conferences ‣ Join online communities ‣ Participate in online forums ‣ Meet new contacts for coffee ‣ Reach out to potential contacts via email or social network sites ‣ Ask friends to introduce you to their contacts as a reliable person ‣ Stay in touch with former coworkers ‣ Go to shows with people
HERE IS MORE!
‣ Get invited to people's houses to have meals with them and watch movies and shows ‣ Hold public discussion groups ‣ Meet with Parents' and Teachers' Association Groups ‣ Get to know and talk to your local medical doctors ‣ Meet with neighborhood clubs ‣ Meet with local health action groups ‣ Join public speaking groups like Toastmasters and Zonta ‣ Meet people at a fancy restaurant, sit down, talk, have meals together ‣ Pay your waiter a tab and converse ‣ Give local schoolchildren a talk about your work so that they can follow in your footsteps and get a career happening ‣ Get to know therapists. GIVE PEOPLE VALUABLE GIFTS. VOLUNTEER.
There are many professions that you could do with a doctorate in a humanities field. One is tutoring. I have been doing it since 1975. Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary students. It is a good source of instant income!
Another is a researcher, in a situation like a remote intern for a university department. They shall know you have a capacity for research as a doctorate armed with the numerous Internet specialist search engines.
You could advertise yourself as a Business Consultant and a Doctor [not medical!], as a PhD., you can use the title. While it is good to have a Master of Business Administration for the business advisor, some consultants are not as qualified! You probably know the reason why many businesses fail! The reason is that the managers carry-on and ignorantly deliberate and procrastinate about important remedial procedures that could rescue the entity.
You want to enter into a specialty without much further studies. There are many successful entrepreneurs too, without doctorates or degrees. If you have a product or service that people desire, or a method that enables them to cope with the latest version of life, then you can win.
GOD BLESS!
Hi James, your middle name caught my attention immediately as my research was in that very area of Constantine. :-) Thank you for all these terrific ideas. I will definitely be referring to your post frequently in the coming week and months as I work to re-form my professional direction.
Andrew
Paul Goetzinger MPA
Academic and Career Consultant and Freelance Writer, TRIO Program Administrator
1009
Answers
Tacoma, Washington
Updated
Paul’s Answer
I would also consider looking into some adult education technical certificate programs, which are normally offered at local junior, community and technical colleges, to help you with possible options.
These short term training and certification classes can be potentially very helpful in assisting you to make career changes and choices.
These certificate and technical programs offer focused, job-oriented training and education to gain or enhance workplace skills in fields like technology, business, and healthcare, or to specialize in future education and training roles such as a corporate trainer, gaming occupations, curriculum developer, community educator and other career and technical oriented certificates.
The programs, are normally designed for career advancement, career changes, and professional development by providing relevant, practical knowledge and skills that lead directly to employment or a deeper understanding of specific industries. David Epstein stated in his book "Range" that the individuals, in our society, who have the most proficient skills in many areas (Generalists), are going to be the ones who eventually will rule the world, and subsequently avoid Artificial Intelligence interference.
So, going the technical college and professional certification route, might be something to seriously look at to further your education and skills.
These short term training and certification classes can be potentially very helpful in assisting you to make career changes and choices.
These certificate and technical programs offer focused, job-oriented training and education to gain or enhance workplace skills in fields like technology, business, and healthcare, or to specialize in future education and training roles such as a corporate trainer, gaming occupations, curriculum developer, community educator and other career and technical oriented certificates.
The programs, are normally designed for career advancement, career changes, and professional development by providing relevant, practical knowledge and skills that lead directly to employment or a deeper understanding of specific industries. David Epstein stated in his book "Range" that the individuals, in our society, who have the most proficient skills in many areas (Generalists), are going to be the ones who eventually will rule the world, and subsequently avoid Artificial Intelligence interference.
So, going the technical college and professional certification route, might be something to seriously look at to further your education and skills.
Suzanne Sorkin
Retired family physician and medical educator
137
Answers
Traverse City, Michigan
Updated
Suzanne’s Answer
Hello Andrew. I have a couple thoughts, one specific and one more general.
The specific thought is: have you considered exploring medical school humanities departments and programs? Many medical schools, both M.D. and osteopathic (D.O.) include some humanities components to their curricula. Some of these positions are listed on places like Indeed but I believe connecting with people in these programs may also help you network and learn of informal, unlisted positions.
The second idea (which, granted may sound hokey, but really needs to be given credence) is to spend some time with one of the career guidance programs available on line. The one I like is o*net
(see link below). These are not just for high school kids but can help you make connections between your skill set, interests, aspirations and careers you may not have thought about. I'd urge you to keep an open mind and to set aside some time and mental energy to explore.
Best of luck, Andrew. My husband had an ABD in a humanities field and ended up with a satisfying career in a Teacher Education program, working with both future teachers as well as current teachers and their pupils.
https://medschool.umich.edu/programs-admissions/md-program/md-curriculum/impact-curriculum/paths-excellence/paths-excellence-medical-humanities
https://www.onetonline.org
The specific thought is: have you considered exploring medical school humanities departments and programs? Many medical schools, both M.D. and osteopathic (D.O.) include some humanities components to their curricula. Some of these positions are listed on places like Indeed but I believe connecting with people in these programs may also help you network and learn of informal, unlisted positions.
The second idea (which, granted may sound hokey, but really needs to be given credence) is to spend some time with one of the career guidance programs available on line. The one I like is o*net
(see link below). These are not just for high school kids but can help you make connections between your skill set, interests, aspirations and careers you may not have thought about. I'd urge you to keep an open mind and to set aside some time and mental energy to explore.
Best of luck, Andrew. My husband had an ABD in a humanities field and ended up with a satisfying career in a Teacher Education program, working with both future teachers as well as current teachers and their pupils.
Suzanne recommends the following next steps:
wendy gibson
Senior Program manager
10
Answers
Omaha, Nebraska
Updated
wendy’s Answer
When I was young in my career, I thought that I wanted to also stay in the academic world, and work in that field forever. However, I quickly realized that the field was not only super competitive, but also very hard to find a job in for long term success that wasn't an adjunct position. For me, the steps I took next was to look for transferable skills that would be useful in the corporate world, which for me was taking my "teaching" skills and turning them into "learning and development" and taking my mentoring skills and applying them to use in management. I also used my skills in communication and the theories that I learned to open up a world of communication, change management and eventually enablement. I think a lot of this is back to reframing how you think about the next steps to take and what skills you have learned in every capacity and how you can use those skills to help better a company and their processes. You sound like you have an AMAZING set of tools at your disposal, and I know that you can use some of those tools in many capacities in the corporate world. The other thing I would mention is that you should never underestimate the value of networking, as you never know what connections are around and how those connections can help you and your career. Good luck and I hope you find something that is fulfilling for you and your skill set!
Shantell Medina-James
Labor relations - Consultant
4
Answers
Yonkers, New York
Updated
Shantell’s Answer
Hello! Have you thought about working with a life coach? As a life coach, I've helped people reach big goals, like getting their doctorates, starting businesses, and creating habits that lead to success. Having someone to guide you, hold you accountable, and provide a clear plan can really help you move from part-time work to a more satisfying career. Best, Coach DeShanti
Chinyere Okafor
Educationist and Counseling Psychologist
1186
Answers
Port Harcourt, Rivers, Nigeria
Updated
Chinyere’s Answer
Hi Andrew,
First of all, sharing all of this takes bravery. You have obviously put in years of hard work, publishing a monograph, obtaining a PhD, and it is normal to feel stuck when the academic road hasn't provided you with stability or respect. What you're going through is sadly common in the humanities at the moment, and it has nothing to do with your worth or intelligence.
A few next steps to consider:
1. Take stock of your transferable skills: The skills you developed throughout your PhD program, such as research and analysis, writing and editing, teaching, public speaking, project management, and cross-cultural communication, are highly employable outside of academia. Start highlighting certain tasks or achievements that highlight these qualities; this will serve as the basis for both interviews and resumes.
2. Explore adjacent fields: Many former academics go on to work in corporate training, policy research, publishing, communications, nonprofit management, higher education administration, or instructional design. Your international experience also fits with global education, cultural organizations, or research institutes.
3. Network intentionally: Make contact with previous academic colleagues who have left the field, sign up for LinkedIn groups for professionals, and think about doing informational interviews with persons in positions that interest you. You can often learn about career paths through conversations rather than job boards.
4. Small experiments: Try out contract research, curriculum development, freelance writing, or volunteering at a nonprofit that interests you before making a significant move. These quick activities boost self-esteem and expand one's skill set.
5. Career coaching or mentorship: You can reframe your experience for new industries and get direction and clarification from a coach who has experience with PhD transitions. Some universities and professional associations offer free or discounted services for alumni.
Your ability to handle challenging work has already been demonstrated; the next step is to apply that skill in an environment that values it. Instead of making all the decisions at once, start with brief discussions and skill assessments, then use those as guidance for your future steps. Your time in school was not in vain; it equipped you with a set of tools that can lead to more opportunities than you may realize.
Best Wishes!
First of all, sharing all of this takes bravery. You have obviously put in years of hard work, publishing a monograph, obtaining a PhD, and it is normal to feel stuck when the academic road hasn't provided you with stability or respect. What you're going through is sadly common in the humanities at the moment, and it has nothing to do with your worth or intelligence.
A few next steps to consider:
1. Take stock of your transferable skills: The skills you developed throughout your PhD program, such as research and analysis, writing and editing, teaching, public speaking, project management, and cross-cultural communication, are highly employable outside of academia. Start highlighting certain tasks or achievements that highlight these qualities; this will serve as the basis for both interviews and resumes.
2. Explore adjacent fields: Many former academics go on to work in corporate training, policy research, publishing, communications, nonprofit management, higher education administration, or instructional design. Your international experience also fits with global education, cultural organizations, or research institutes.
3. Network intentionally: Make contact with previous academic colleagues who have left the field, sign up for LinkedIn groups for professionals, and think about doing informational interviews with persons in positions that interest you. You can often learn about career paths through conversations rather than job boards.
4. Small experiments: Try out contract research, curriculum development, freelance writing, or volunteering at a nonprofit that interests you before making a significant move. These quick activities boost self-esteem and expand one's skill set.
5. Career coaching or mentorship: You can reframe your experience for new industries and get direction and clarification from a coach who has experience with PhD transitions. Some universities and professional associations offer free or discounted services for alumni.
Your ability to handle challenging work has already been demonstrated; the next step is to apply that skill in an environment that values it. Instead of making all the decisions at once, start with brief discussions and skill assessments, then use those as guidance for your future steps. Your time in school was not in vain; it equipped you with a set of tools that can lead to more opportunities than you may realize.
Best Wishes!
These are all terrific ideas, and I deeply appreciate your encouragement here. It helps me entertain a much more positive perspective than I've been having about my professional prospects for awhile. :-)
Andrew
Eric Behrens, MA
Information Technology, Chief Information Officer
1
Answer
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Updated
Eric’s Answer
Andrew, congratulations on your scholarly achievements. I suspect that the work skills and disciplinary methodologies you used have given you some hidden superpowers. We tend to minimize the value of critical thinking, writing, rhetoric, collaboration, research, etc. by calling them "soft skills." We should be calling them power skills. Having been a manager/leader in higher education administration for decades, they are the capabilities that will distinguish you in any field you enter.
The crossroads you have reached is quite common as competition for the full-time tenured academic jobs has become fiercer. Beyond the scholarly subject matter, you might consider what factors drew you to pursue a professorial career. Did you love working in museums and archives? Analysis? Perfecting pedagogy? Working with students? Advising? Writing? Intersections with cutting edge work in digital humanities?
There is a large community of people who pursued Alt-ac (alternate academic) careers. Many university VPs, Deans of Students, and other leadership positions are filled by people with doctorate degrees. There are also opportunities in many other industries, as other responders have mentioned. The stories of alt-ac workers is incredibly diverse. As just one example, here's a recent post from one professional: https://theprofessorisin.com/2025/02/18/breaking-the-mold-navigating-new-academic-paths-through-alt-ac-careers-a-guest-post/.
Best wishes on finding a fulfilling new path to follow.
Explore blog posts and discussions online among scholars who identify as Alt-ac.
If applicable, connect with your alma mater's graduate career services office to learn about pathways that other PhDs and ABDs have followed.
Network with students and professionals who have pursued alt-ac careers. They're more likely to be found on LinkedIn that traditional professors.
The crossroads you have reached is quite common as competition for the full-time tenured academic jobs has become fiercer. Beyond the scholarly subject matter, you might consider what factors drew you to pursue a professorial career. Did you love working in museums and archives? Analysis? Perfecting pedagogy? Working with students? Advising? Writing? Intersections with cutting edge work in digital humanities?
There is a large community of people who pursued Alt-ac (alternate academic) careers. Many university VPs, Deans of Students, and other leadership positions are filled by people with doctorate degrees. There are also opportunities in many other industries, as other responders have mentioned. The stories of alt-ac workers is incredibly diverse. As just one example, here's a recent post from one professional: https://theprofessorisin.com/2025/02/18/breaking-the-mold-navigating-new-academic-paths-through-alt-ac-careers-a-guest-post/.
Best wishes on finding a fulfilling new path to follow.
Eric recommends the following next steps:
Arush Anand
Associate Architect
20
Answers
Bengaluru, Karnataka, India
Updated
Arush’s Answer
Hi Andrew,
Thank you for sharing so openly—it takes courage to put your situation into words. From what you’ve written, a few key themes stand out:
You’ve invested deeply in scholarship (PhD, monograph, adjunct teaching) but the academic job market has been unforgiving.
You’ve gained work experience outside academia, but advancement opportunities seem blocked and instability is growing.
You’re searching for direction, ideally something that leverages your background, but you also want stability, fair pay, and room to thrive.
Here are some thoughts and possible next steps, framed in a practical way:
1. Reframe Your Strengths Beyond Academia
With a PhD and published research, you bring a lot of value even if academia doesn’t fully recognize it:
Research & analysis – breaking down complex material, identifying patterns, synthesizing insights.
Writing & communication – publishing a monograph is a massive proof of clarity, discipline, and thought leadership.
Teaching & presenting – you’ve already taught; this translates directly to training, consulting, or public engagement roles.
Project management – completing a PhD is essentially managing a long-term, complex project with limited resources.
Framing your background in terms of transferable skills is the first step toward pivoting.
2. Explore Career Pathways Aligned with Your Profile
You may find fulfillment (and better pay) in careers where your skill set is rare and valued. Some potential areas:
Knowledge industries: publishing, policy research, think tanks, nonprofits, museums, libraries, cultural institutions.
Corporate sector: learning & development, instructional design, research roles in user experience (UX), content strategy, corporate communications.
Government & NGOs: policy analysis, grant writing, program evaluation, advocacy.
Independent path: consulting, freelance editing, curriculum development, or coaching (where your expertise can be packaged).
3. Tackle the Vulnerability Head-On
Given the layoffs and stalled promotions:
Short-term security: Keep options open for stable roles that may not be your dream job but cover financial security.
Parallel exploration: While working, allocate time to investigate and test-drive new directions (online courses, volunteering, freelance projects).
Networking strategy: Many non-academic opportunities don’t appear on job boards; they come through contacts. Start with informational interviews—short conversations where you ask people in roles you admire about their career path.
4. Practical First Steps
Skill translation exercise: Rewrite your CV as a professional resume geared toward non-academic roles. (I can help with that if you’d like.)
Targeted learning: Consider quick certifications to bridge gaps—e.g., instructional design, UX research, or nonprofit management.
Networking: Join professional associations or LinkedIn groups outside academia. You’ll find ex-academics who’ve pivoted.
Career design tools: Look into Designing Your Life (by Bill Burnett & Dave Evans) or the ImaginePhD platform—both designed for professionals seeking direction.
5. Mindset Shift
It’s common for people leaving academia to feel like they’ve “failed”—but really, you’re in a transition phase. You’ve already proven discipline, expertise, and adaptability; the challenge now is about translation and direction, not worthiness.
Regards,
Arush
Thank you for sharing so openly—it takes courage to put your situation into words. From what you’ve written, a few key themes stand out:
You’ve invested deeply in scholarship (PhD, monograph, adjunct teaching) but the academic job market has been unforgiving.
You’ve gained work experience outside academia, but advancement opportunities seem blocked and instability is growing.
You’re searching for direction, ideally something that leverages your background, but you also want stability, fair pay, and room to thrive.
Here are some thoughts and possible next steps, framed in a practical way:
1. Reframe Your Strengths Beyond Academia
With a PhD and published research, you bring a lot of value even if academia doesn’t fully recognize it:
Research & analysis – breaking down complex material, identifying patterns, synthesizing insights.
Writing & communication – publishing a monograph is a massive proof of clarity, discipline, and thought leadership.
Teaching & presenting – you’ve already taught; this translates directly to training, consulting, or public engagement roles.
Project management – completing a PhD is essentially managing a long-term, complex project with limited resources.
Framing your background in terms of transferable skills is the first step toward pivoting.
2. Explore Career Pathways Aligned with Your Profile
You may find fulfillment (and better pay) in careers where your skill set is rare and valued. Some potential areas:
Knowledge industries: publishing, policy research, think tanks, nonprofits, museums, libraries, cultural institutions.
Corporate sector: learning & development, instructional design, research roles in user experience (UX), content strategy, corporate communications.
Government & NGOs: policy analysis, grant writing, program evaluation, advocacy.
Independent path: consulting, freelance editing, curriculum development, or coaching (where your expertise can be packaged).
3. Tackle the Vulnerability Head-On
Given the layoffs and stalled promotions:
Short-term security: Keep options open for stable roles that may not be your dream job but cover financial security.
Parallel exploration: While working, allocate time to investigate and test-drive new directions (online courses, volunteering, freelance projects).
Networking strategy: Many non-academic opportunities don’t appear on job boards; they come through contacts. Start with informational interviews—short conversations where you ask people in roles you admire about their career path.
4. Practical First Steps
Skill translation exercise: Rewrite your CV as a professional resume geared toward non-academic roles. (I can help with that if you’d like.)
Targeted learning: Consider quick certifications to bridge gaps—e.g., instructional design, UX research, or nonprofit management.
Networking: Join professional associations or LinkedIn groups outside academia. You’ll find ex-academics who’ve pivoted.
Career design tools: Look into Designing Your Life (by Bill Burnett & Dave Evans) or the ImaginePhD platform—both designed for professionals seeking direction.
5. Mindset Shift
It’s common for people leaving academia to feel like they’ve “failed”—but really, you’re in a transition phase. You’ve already proven discipline, expertise, and adaptability; the challenge now is about translation and direction, not worthiness.
Regards,
Arush
Wong Loke Yuen
Head of Programme cum Senior Lecturer
645
Answers
Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia
Updated
Wong’s Answer
Hi Andrew. You have a strong background with your PhD and research, so you have many useful skills. One idea is to look for jobs outside of schools where your skills are needed. For example, nonprofit groups, publishing companies, or museums might want someone who can think deeply and explain ideas well. You could try talking to people who work in these areas to learn more about the jobs and what they do.
Another option is to use your teaching experience in places like educational technology, making learning materials, or training workers in companies. Many businesses need people who can create courses and help others learn, and these jobs can be more stable than part-time teaching.
It might help to think about what parts of your past jobs you liked the most, such as helping students, writing, or doing research. This can help you find work that fits your interests and skills. You might also want to get help from a career coach or attend workshops to learn how to change careers and meet new people.
Meeting new people is very important. Joining groups, going to events, or joining online communities related to your interests can help you find new job opportunities. Remember, your PhD and experience are special and many employers want someone like you. The key is to find jobs where your skills are useful. Taking small steps to explore different options will help you find a path where you can succeed and feel happy. All the best!
Another option is to use your teaching experience in places like educational technology, making learning materials, or training workers in companies. Many businesses need people who can create courses and help others learn, and these jobs can be more stable than part-time teaching.
It might help to think about what parts of your past jobs you liked the most, such as helping students, writing, or doing research. This can help you find work that fits your interests and skills. You might also want to get help from a career coach or attend workshops to learn how to change careers and meet new people.
Meeting new people is very important. Joining groups, going to events, or joining online communities related to your interests can help you find new job opportunities. Remember, your PhD and experience are special and many employers want someone like you. The key is to find jobs where your skills are useful. Taking small steps to explore different options will help you find a path where you can succeed and feel happy. All the best!
Thank you, Wong for the advice.
Andrew
Meeting people is something I've always struggled with, as far as both initiating contact and doing so in a way that does not communicate that I want something for myself rather than the relationship itself. I have a broad variety of contacts in numerous fields, but they are not really areas of interest for me. However, they are wonderful people and I do learn a great deal from them. As I'm sure you know well, getting into academia in the US and in other areas of the world is very much about "Who You Know" and I confess to having done a poor job in that area during my doctorate.
Andrew
You are welcome.
Wong Loke Yuen
JM Jackson
Consulting
13
Answers
Covington, Georgia
Updated
JM’s Answer
Our nation USA is in a crisis! You have a proven track record of taking lemons and making lemonade. You are a "survivor" despite being at a breaking point you preservered. That in itself shows your strengths of determination and persistence. Surely, you observed students who turned in excellent work versus poor work. You observed how some student had no motivation to overcome while others were determined not to fail. Write a self-help book to help the students of this current age. They need directions, clarity, organizational skilks, something like: " Study-habits that create A+ in weeks!" Or "Overcoming personal problems to acheive top grades fast!" Not grammatically sound, but I hope you understand. You are a teacher, which means you can teach anything!!! You are not limited to what you studied. Open your net and cast it into corporate. Science and engineering, IT. Google teaching positions, tutoring positions, learning centers careers, look for grants teaching low income communities, maybe there are some students with comprehension issues you can help? I have no way of knowing what prompted these learning centers to open, but can you see yourself leading one or developing you own? Google listed,
"Top learning centers in the U.S. include Kumon, Mathnasium, Sylvan Learning, Huntington Learning Center, Varsity Tutors, and Tutor Doctor,"
Opportunity, flexibility and even putting into an Ai search engine this question, "This is my degree _______,what higher paying opportunitues can I obtain with ?
Is Fiverr an option for you?
Don't give up! Wise up and use the Ai search engines to help you craft a book to meet needs toward a passive income stream.
Tiktok, FB, YouTube have content creators who looked at their strength, found their passion and are teaching us everything under the sun with flair, passion and energy. Is this an option for you?
You are smart!!! You brillantly survived post coronavirus, now seek big Fortune 500 companies for "trainer roles" and try you hand at something different. The journey of 1000 miles starts with a single step, but take your car ...it will be faster : )
"Top learning centers in the U.S. include Kumon, Mathnasium, Sylvan Learning, Huntington Learning Center, Varsity Tutors, and Tutor Doctor,"
Opportunity, flexibility and even putting into an Ai search engine this question, "This is my degree _______,what higher paying opportunitues can I obtain with ?
Is Fiverr an option for you?
Don't give up! Wise up and use the Ai search engines to help you craft a book to meet needs toward a passive income stream.
Tiktok, FB, YouTube have content creators who looked at their strength, found their passion and are teaching us everything under the sun with flair, passion and energy. Is this an option for you?
You are smart!!! You brillantly survived post coronavirus, now seek big Fortune 500 companies for "trainer roles" and try you hand at something different. The journey of 1000 miles starts with a single step, but take your car ...it will be faster : )
Thank you very much, JM. These are great ideas and I will certainly take each into account while I continue moving forward.
Andrew
George Zou, M.S.
Academic Advisor
36
Answers
Fort Wayne, Indiana
Updated
George’s Answer
Hi Andrew,
I know things are tough right now, but you're not alone. Many people with PhDs in the humanities face challenges finding full-time teaching jobs, and it doesn't mean you're not capable. You've achieved so much already—earning a PhD, publishing research, teaching students, and juggling multiple jobs. This shows you're hardworking and skilled. You're not "lost," just in a transition phase. You need to find jobs that match your skills and interests. Think about what you enjoyed during your PhD or teaching, what work environment suits you, and what you need most right now, like a steady income or meaningful work.
There are plenty of jobs that could suit you. Consider research roles like UX research, market research, or policy research. Writing and communication jobs such as technical writing, grant writing, content strategy, or instructional design are also great options. In education, roles like academic advising or program coordination could use your teaching experience. Nonprofit work in program management or community engagement is another path. Corporate jobs in HR, talent development, or training might also be a good fit. These roles value your skills in thinking, writing, research, and teaching.
Next, update your résumé for these types of jobs, choose two or three areas to explore, network with people in those fields, and start applying to positions that suit your needs and skills. Your PhD and research experience are strengths, not obstacles. With a clear plan and small steps, you can find a stable and fulfilling career that matches your skills and life.
I know things are tough right now, but you're not alone. Many people with PhDs in the humanities face challenges finding full-time teaching jobs, and it doesn't mean you're not capable. You've achieved so much already—earning a PhD, publishing research, teaching students, and juggling multiple jobs. This shows you're hardworking and skilled. You're not "lost," just in a transition phase. You need to find jobs that match your skills and interests. Think about what you enjoyed during your PhD or teaching, what work environment suits you, and what you need most right now, like a steady income or meaningful work.
There are plenty of jobs that could suit you. Consider research roles like UX research, market research, or policy research. Writing and communication jobs such as technical writing, grant writing, content strategy, or instructional design are also great options. In education, roles like academic advising or program coordination could use your teaching experience. Nonprofit work in program management or community engagement is another path. Corporate jobs in HR, talent development, or training might also be a good fit. These roles value your skills in thinking, writing, research, and teaching.
Next, update your résumé for these types of jobs, choose two or three areas to explore, network with people in those fields, and start applying to positions that suit your needs and skills. Your PhD and research experience are strengths, not obstacles. With a clear plan and small steps, you can find a stable and fulfilling career that matches your skills and life.
Delete Comment
Flag Comment